Is this a Bassian Thrush ?

23 posts / 0 new
Last post
tracviet2000
tracviet2000's picture
Is this a Bassian Thrush ?

I took these pictures yesterday at Brisbane QD. Is this a Bassian Thrush ?

Thanks,

Trac

pacman
pacman's picture

no, the Bassian Thrush is found above 500m altitude;it is not a thrush, did you look inside the field guide to identify the bird's family

Peter

teganb02
teganb02's picture

That's a female Australasian Fig bird I'm pretty sure.

Tegan - Melbourne Vic.

Reflex
Reflex's picture

I agree with Tegan. Female Figbird.

Samford Valley Qld.

zosterops
zosterops's picture

i can see how it could be confused with a thrush. 

tracviet2000
tracviet2000's picture

Thanks Peter, Tegan, Zosterops and Reflex. I was matching the size, markings and colours without in depth knowledge of these birds. I guess that this is part of learning curve.

Woko
Woko's picture

It certainly is, tracviet. Good on you for having a go at identifying the bird & then seeking confirmation. You'll begin to find that more of your hypotheses will be accurate. If you're not already you'll then begin to make identifications & be able to substantiate them with observations of birds' features, including behaviour & location both in the environment & on a map.

teganb02
teganb02's picture

Are you sure Woko? I thought we already identified it as a female Australaisian Figbird?? Because Bassian Thrushes are more scalloped on their chest to the their back, but this bird has no scalloping on the back and has streaks instead on the chest? The beak and the head shape are different too. Sorry if I am contradicting you :))

Tegan - Melbourne Vic.

Reflex
Reflex's picture

teganb02 wrote:

Are you sure Woko? I thought we already identified it as a female Australaisian Figbird?? Because Bassian Thrushes are more scalloped on their chest to the their back, but this bird has no scalloping on the back and has streaks instead on the chest? The beak and the head shape are different too. Sorry if I am contradicting you :))

 Woko was referring to the learning curve not the bird.

Samford Valley Qld.

davethewonder
davethewonder's picture

Yes it's a F Figbird. On a side note, I've had Bassian Thrush in a dense gully in Sydney's North and regularly at the Royal National Park south of Sydney (including one 2 weeks ago), so it seems they do have some altitudinal movement down towards sea level. 

Dave, Sydney. 

tracviet2000
tracviet2000's picture

Thanks Woko and Tegan.

soakes
soakes's picture

pacman wrote:

no, the Bassian Thrush is found above 500m altitude;

Where did you get this idea?  I have seen them at much lower altitudes.

soakes
Olinda, Victoria, Australia

zosterops
zosterops's picture

i've seen them at sea level 

Reflex
Reflex's picture

zosterops wrote:

i've seen them at sea level 

 Are you sure it wasn't a Russet-tailed Thrush? Very similar bird.

Samford Valley Qld.

zosterops
zosterops's picture

Well it was in Victoria where only the Bassian occurs (Song Thrush may occur as a rare vagrant from Melb population)

Reflex
Reflex's picture

Lol! You know your birds Zosterops. We have both in SE Queensland and making a positive ID can be tricky.

Samford Valley Qld.

pacman
pacman's picture

soakes wrote:
pacman wrote:

no, the Bassian Thrush is found above 500m altitude;

Where did you get this idea?  I have seen them at much lower altitudes.

Morcombe's Field Guide (2009 reprint) and App (2010 - never updated) says Bassian above 500m and Russet-tailed to 750m

maybe I need to check the current editions to see if he has changed this information

does anyone have access to HANZAB to check what it says?

Pizzey & Knight (2012) says the same

Simpson & Day (2010) make no mention

Peter

zosterops
zosterops's picture

sounds like you've collected some field guides there, pacman. 

Araminta
Araminta's picture

Peter, I have a few Bassian Thrushes in my garden. I might check how high up the hill I live?

I just checked, I'm 113m above sea level.

M-L

Araminta
Araminta's picture

one on my Poo-pile.

M-L

soakes
soakes's picture

Beautiful.  I've never been able to get that close.

According to the distribution map they are all over the south-east, and some in Queensland.  Perhaps in the warmer climates they are opnly at higher altitudes.

http://www.birdsinbackyards.net/species/Zoothera-lunulata

("Related factsheets" link not working.)

soakes
Olinda, Victoria, Australia

dwatsonbb
dwatsonbb's picture

Hi Soakes, have just tested fact sheet, and now appears ok. Perhaps send Holly a PM if your still having trouble.

Dale Huonville, Tasmania

pacman
pacman's picture

zosterops wrote:

sounds like you've collected some field guides there, pacman.

yes, good to have different infomration sources as sometimes they are wrong - apparently wrong for Bassian Thrush

Peter

 and   @birdsinbackyards
                 Subscribe to me on YouTube