Pacific Splashdown!

28 posts / 0 new
Last post
tarkineus
tarkineus's picture
Pacific Splashdown!

Pacific Black Ducklanding on the marsh and I think the last picture is perhaps a junior.

stevehapp
stevehapp's picture

tark, sorry to be a party pooper, mate.
but I don't think 1 & 2 are Pacific Black Ducks.
I cant work out what they are.
and
I think 3 is a Chestnut Teal.
:)
cheers,
steve

ed
ed's picture

hi Tark

Love that action shots, are they all the same bird? definatly Chestnut Teal

Ed Townsville NQ

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Not a party pooper at all, Steve. We may have mis identified them from the book. Maybe Denis can help us out with a diagnostic ID.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

ed - I can tell you that #1 and #2 is the same bird, but #3 was taken about an hour earlier at the same location.
Thanks to you and steve for the ID on the Chestnut Teal.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

ed
ed's picture

Hi Tark
Still pretty sure #1 and #2 are CT.Your pictures show the difficulty of ID from photos....those birds have a deep blue/black head, don't they ?? I'm sure you know the head was green, as you saw the bird in the field, but the photo shows a differently, in this case all the other features say "CT" but at other times photo ID based on colour can be very mis-leading....I'm starting to sound like Denis.... :-).
Hi Denis only kiddin,if we all took the time you do to explain our reasons for ID we would all learn a lot quicker...Thanks.

Ed Townsville NQ

smeedingo2
smeedingo2's picture

HI Tark
Chestnut teal for me all 3. Blackducks don't have the white flank.

stevehapp
stevehapp's picture

I have been thinking Chestnut Teal for 1 & 2 due to some weird light/colour aberation/ darkening effect on the neck..
,
interesting discussion but..

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

ed - dingo - steve, #1 and #2 did have a blueblack head as the picture shows. Sandra found a bird that looks very much like it in a book of Tasmanian birds. That's about all I can tell you.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

Tassie

Nice shots Tark, I think I will leave 1 and 2 to the experts.
:)

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Thanks Tassie ... will be interested to hear Denis's verdict. I rescued this bad file from the trashcan but it may help ID it. It's looking more and more like a Chestnut Teal with that white flash on its side, but the head is definately blueblack.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

raysimula
raysimula's picture

Dennis did explain this once before with one of my pics. It seems that the green can only be seen when the light shines off the head at the right angle.Check out you'r pic 3 and you will see that only part of the head is showing green.
Ray

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Thanks Ray, that would explain it. The first two were backlit whereas the last was frontally lit.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

smeedingo2
smeedingo2's picture

HI Tark
You may have a cross as it does sit in the water lower and it's head looks a different shape beak longer you will have to try and get some close shots for us mate thanks for sharing.

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Hi dingo - I'll be revisiting that rich location sometime soon and will hopefully will be lucky enough to get a clearer shot. Problem is that access to the site is mostly from the south, which means that downunder downunder you must shoot against the light.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

DenisWilson
DenisWilson's picture

Hi everybody - Can't a guy leave town for 2 days?
.
Definitely first 3 images areimages of a male Chestnut Teal.
The 3rd image is a classic male Chestnut Teal, complete with the red eye. It should be kept as a "reference" image.
The white spot on the flanks and white underwing "wing pits" fits perfectly with the BiBY description.
http://birdsinbackyards.net/finder/display.cfm?id=200
.
Re the last image - (different time and place, it seems) it does appear somewhat different, but I am inclined to say Chestnut Teal still. I am discounting the blue vs green for the moment. The Australasian Shoveler has a brown body and white patch on the flank, but it a much larger duck, with a distinctively shaped head and a very long bill.
BiBY says: "The Australasian Shoveler is a low-floating, dark headed duck, with a low sloping forehead blending to a heavy, square-cut, shovel-tipped bill. The male in breeding plumage has a deep grey-blue head with a vertical white crescent between the bright-yellow eye and the bill The back and rump are black, and the shoulder and wing coverts are blue-grey with several white bars. The underparts are chestnut, with white patches to the rear of the flanks."
And further on BiBY also says:
"The breeding plumage of the Australasian Shoveler is similar to the Chestnut Teal, A. castanea, though this is a much smaller bird, with a green, rather than blue, head and a less massive bill. When dabbling, (feeding with head under the water) the Shoveler's orange legs are distinctive."
http://birdsinbackyards.net/finder/display.cfm?id=210
.
Here is a set of images from the Canberra Ornithologists Gallery for the Australasian Shoveler. http://photogallery.canberrabirds.org.au/swan_ducks.htm#AUSV The really clear images (several of them) show grey or bluish head, long sloping beak, yellow eye and a very distinctive white stripe in front of the eye. The white a spot on the flanks is relatively small. This species does appear to sit lower on the water, but even the 4th image above does not have the correct beak shape and head angle.
.
Re the apparent blue or black or green head, the colour is more apparent than real. It is not created by pigment, but is referred to as a "structural colour".
Read this explanation from a fellow blogger of mine.
http://snailseyeview.blogspot.com/2006/12/why-blue-birds-are-blue.html.
.
Tark has already acknowledged the problem of the angle of the sun. That definitely changes the appearance.
.
Hope these comments help.
Cheers
Denis

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Thanks Denis, the links and your information is most helpful. I found snail's explanation of the difference between structural and pigmental plumage colour especially interesting and useful.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Denis, pic #4 directly above has me puzzled though because it is the same bird taken seconds after its splashdown and it clearly has a black beak, whereas the Chestnut Teal below has a yellow beak? I admit to becoming increasingly confused over this ID.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

Gelmir
Gelmir's picture

G'day Tark,
Your latest photo is of a Male and Female Northern Mallard. The Mallards are larger than the Chestnut Teals, and are an introduced species. The breed with PBD's, which can be confusing sometimes for ID'ing purposes.

DenisWilson
DenisWilson's picture

Hi Tark
.
Gelmir is right. Your most recently posted image is of a pair of Mallards, possibly not pure bred birds. The Mallard is considerably larger than even a Pacific Black Duck, and much larger than your Chestnut Teals.
.
There are many repeated "themes" in duck plumage which make IDs a bit confusing. For example Shelduck males have a dark head, sometimes greenish., and have a white ring around the throat, just as your, male Mallard does. But with a suite of features, such as wing markings, habits, etc, they fall into different groups and one can ID them (eventually).
Australian Shelduck.
http://www.birdsinbackyards.net/bird/209
Mallard
http://www.birdsinbackyards.net/bird/184
Note the curled up tail feathers on the Mallard. Legs are always orange, but the Shoveler also has orange legs, but its beak is quite different.
Keep on battling. You will get the hang of them all.
Cheers
Denis

ed
ed's picture

Hi All
Just to see the results I've just tried a Google image searh for 'chestnut teal', try it and see how many are incorrectly labled....

Ed Townsville NQ

ed
ed's picture

Hi All
Just to see the results I've just tried a Google image searh for 'chestnut teal'.... try it and see how many are incorrectly labled....not the best way to get an ID. !!

Ed Townsville NQ

ed
ed's picture

the old 'page 2' trick again.

Ed Townsville NQ

DenisWilson
DenisWilson's picture

Hi Ed
I know that problem - You keep "posting" and nothing appears to happen, so you try again. Bugger! Page 2
I did the Google Image Search and found a few odd results, including a Fairy Penguin.
.
However I did find this - a Guide to Waterfowl.
http://www.dse.vic.gov.au/DSE/nrenrt.nsf/LinkView/DA3E15465FED1BB7CA257376001DA17FC1DB2757E23C4965CA257376001BB03F
.
It is posted by the Victorian Dept which controls Duck Hunting (don't start me on that!).
.
But it has good sketches of all the birds we have been talking about, with body sketches, images of birds in flight, showing diagnostic wing patches, upper and under, etc.
It is very good. We should all "bookmark it" or save as a "Favourite".
.
I shall post it on its own page as well, to help people find it (as it is hidden on Page 2 here).
.
Cheers
Denis

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Gelmir - thanks for the ID on the last posting which I would have mistaken for Chestnut Teals. Now the acronym, "PBD's" - you mean Pure Bread Ducks?
.
Denis - Thanks for the links that I've studied closely although I doubt that I'll ever be able to retain the differences in my head, which is an untidy repository at any time. Duck morals that aren't exactly kosher simply add to my confusion.

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Hi ed, I almost fell for the old P.2 trap again myself - only an innate skepticism saved me!

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

Gelmir
Gelmir's picture

G'day Tark,
PBD is short for Pacific Black Duck. I'm just a bit lazy sometimes to write it all. :^)

tarkineus
tarkineus's picture

Thanks Gelmir - and how thick am I! (rhetorical)

Regards, "Tark" - Olympus 4/3rds colour

 and   @birdsinbackyards
                 Subscribe to me on YouTube