Common Blackbird or what?

10 posts / 0 new
Last post
wazza.willson
wazza.willson's picture
Common Blackbird or what?

This seems like the common Blackbird (introduced) but the length and curvature of the beak leave me in doubt. Any suggestions?

Andy
Andy's picture

I think it might be a Starling (introduced).

Woko
Woko's picture

Looks like a starling to me.

wazza.willson
wazza.willson's picture

Thanks Andy and Woko. I have since seen a much better comparison shot and I have no doubt it is a blackbird, although the starling does look close in breeding plumage. Unfortunately my image isn't a particularly good shot, so it's very difficult to tell from that, but the markings on the rump and nape were identical to the comparison shot of a blackbird seen recently. Thanks again for your help. yes

Andy
Andy's picture

No worries :-)

My thought is still that it's a Starling, due partly to the length and curve of the beak, the speckling, and the lack of a yellow eye-ring. Was the bird in the comparison shot (which this bird resembled) definitely a Blackbird?

It's always good fun trying to solve a bird mystery!

Andy.

wazza.willson
wazza.willson's picture

Andy wrote:
Was the bird in the comparison shot (which this bird resembled) definitely a Blackbird?

It's always good fun trying to solve a bird mystery!

It was used to illustrate a story on blackbirds getting drunk on fermented berries and was supplied by Getty so it's anyone's guess really. The beak length was similar, including the curve at the end, and the mottling of the rump and nape also. Here's another story, with illustrative image showing the mottling, but not the long curved beak. 

I'm not set against the Starling ID, but the subject bird's beak was a bright orange (even though the sample image doesn't show that - I had to desaturate, and open up the shadows a little so the mottling was visible). 

The thing that made me think blackbird originally, rather than starling, was also the ground foraging habit of having its tail feathers up, like a willy wagtail only much bigger. I've never seen starlings do that, but I'm a rank novice at this game.

I'm glad I presented something of a challenge, Andy. I'd hate to post something that 15 users all said was a "common" something-or-other, and "why didn't I just look up the list here". cheeky

Araminta
Araminta's picture

Sorry wazza, I grew up in Europe, where Blackbirds and Starlings are the most common birds in every garden. The bird in the photo is not a blackbird, but it is a "Starling"., just like Andy and Woko are saying. There is no doubt in my mind.

M-L

wazza.willson
wazza.willson's picture

Thanks for the definitive assessment, Araminta. yes

Woko
Woko's picture

Wazza, the behaviour you describe is more in keeping with that of a black bird but it still looks like a starling to me. The speckled flank & wing primaries, the lack of a yellow eye ring & the longer, narrower bill all say starling to me.

wazza.willson
wazza.willson's picture

Thanks, Woko. yes

 and   @birdsinbackyards
                 Subscribe to me on YouTube