The breeding seasons of the three Noisy Pitta subspecies are slightly different. Subspecies simillima in norther Cape York breeds October to March, but from January to April in Torres Strait. Subspecies intermedia breeds from October to January and in June in north-east Queensland. Versicolor lays from July to February in south-east Queensland and north-east New South Wales.
The nesting site is usually on the ground within rainforest or closed forest. It is usually in such sites as between buttress roots, at the base of a tree, or besides an object like a log or a rock. The nest is a dome-shaped structure with a side entrance. It is made of materials such as sticks, leaves, rootlets, bark and grass. It is lined with finer material. It often has an entrance platform. Both parents build the nest and materials are collected from the forest floor.Both parents assist in incubation and both feed the chicks.